Ad Draft Model: Weak to Strong
A strong advertisement is not just a decorated product. Compare two drafts and see how audience, benefit, and design change the whole message.
Success criteria
- I can explain why a draft is weak or strong.
- I can improve a draft by adding audience, benefit, and visual hierarchy.
- I can write a rationale that justifies my choices.
Draft A: weak
Marlow notebooks
Buy our notebooks. They are good quality and great value. 20% off!
Notebook. Pencil. Desk.
Buy now.
Why Draft A is weak
- It has no clear audience.
- It lists features and generic praise but no benefit.
- The headline could belong to any stationery brand.
- The image idea is a cliché and does not create a feeling.
- The discount is the only specific detail, so price does all the work.
- The call to action is generic.
Draft B: stronger
MARLOW
For ideas that won't sit still.
Pocket notebooks for sketches, lists, and the thoughts that arrive at 11pm.
Three sizes. Recycled paper. Made to be carried.
Start a page.
Visual: a navy notebook and a pencil on a warm desk, with a burnt-orange button.
What changed
| Choice | Draft A | Draft B | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audience | Unclear | Students and young creatives | The copy can now speak to a specific kind of person. |
| Headline | Brand name plus generic praise | “For ideas that won't sit still” | Personifies ideas and creates an energetic, creative voice. |
| Benefit | “Good quality” | Capture ideas before they disappear | The product now solves a meaningful problem. |
| Specific detail | “20% off” | “the thoughts that arrive at 11pm” | The detail feels human and relatable. |
| Image | Generic object list | Notebook in use, warm desk, pencil | The product feels tactile and real. |
| Colour | None specified | Ink blue, cream, burnt orange | The palette creates a thoughtful, analogue identity; orange directs action. |
| Call to action | “Buy now” | “Start a page” | The action is concrete, creative, and low-pressure. |
The design choices
| Design element | Choice | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Salience | Large serif headline and high-contrast notebook. | The viewer sees the promise and the product first. |
| Reading path | Logo top-left, headline left, image right, CTA bottom-left. | The eye moves from brand to promise to proof to action. |
| Contrast | Navy and cream with a burnt-orange button. | The button stands out without breaking the palette. |
| Typography | Serif headline; mono caption; clean sans-serif body. | The mix feels literary but designed, not old-fashioned. |
| White space | Generous margins around the copy. | The ad feels calm and premium rather than crowded. |
Model rationale
The advertisement targets students and young creatives who want to capture ideas and see themselves as thoughtful and imaginative. The headline, “For ideas that won't sit still,” personifies ideas to make creativity feel energetic rather than tidy. The navy notebook and warm desk image make the product feel tactile and used, while the cream background and serif type create a literary, unpretentious voice. The burnt-orange call to action, “Start a page,” is the only saturated warm element, so it draws the eye after the headline. Unlike a discount ad, this draft sells an identity: the buyer is someone who notices ideas and gives them a place to live. The main risk is that the ad may feel too quiet for a younger audience, so a social media version would need a faster hook and a clearer price.
Why the rationale works
- It names the audience and the brand voice.
- It uses specific evidence from the draft.
- It explains the effect of each choice, not just the choice.
- It acknowledges a weakness.
- It stays focused on positioning, not plot summary.
Your turn
- Take your planning sheet.
- Write a deliberately weak draft in five minutes: generic headline, no audience, no benefit.
- Revise it using the strong draft as a model.
- Annotate three choices: image, colour, and headline.
- Write one paragraph explaining how your draft positions the audience.
Teacher notes
The weak draft is useful because students can diagnose it. Do not skip it.
Ask students to name the audience for Draft B and the evidence that supports their answer.
When students write their rationale, ban “it catches the eye” unless they explain how.
Use the model rationale as a mentor text, not a template to copy. Students should choose different evidence.